How to Make Stevia Extract

Bottle of stevia extract sitting on a window sill

I’m a drug addict. Some days it’s all I think about, that white stuff that makes me feel so good. But it’s not just the ubiquitous white granulated crystals that we all have stashed away. I’m equal opportunity. Molasses, coconut sugar, date sugar, honey, maple and agave syrup, c’mon over. I have an entire shelf dedicated to you guys. Sugar may be one of the biggest addictions today and we hook the kids when they’re young, barely old enough to walk.

At some point this year, about the time I realized two desserts a day were no longer enough to satisfy me, I faced the sober truth that I had a problem. No amount of healthy greens and grains – and I eat a lot of kale and quinoa – was going to offset this much sugar. I decided to eliminate sugar from my diet for one week, and because this is the age of social media, I found a buddy group through a Twitter party so I wouldn’t be traveling alone. I figured I could do anything for a week.

It wasn’t easy. Sugar is added to more foods than you would imagine. I was overwhelmingly aware of nightly bombardments of sugar-infused TV commercials after dinner. And all those sugar and chocolate treats deliberately placed within easy reach for the impulse buy while I waited to put my kale on the conveyor belt at the grocery store was just mean.

I wavered. Completely eliminating sugar just wasn’t realistic. I hopped online to research alternative sugars. Stevia shot to the top of the list with its carb- and calorie-free benefits. But like anything else connected with food these days, there was controversy. A lot of stevia on the grocery shelves is highly processed, with much of it mixed with various forms of sugar like dextrose. I couldn’t win.

And then I found a couple of plants at the nursery. You’d have thought I found a suitcase of money. I was that excited.

My first experiment was to dry some leaves and whirl them in a spice grinder. I added a pinch of the stevia powder to my morning yogurt and was thrilled with the result. It doesn’t take much to do the trick since the leaves are 30 – 50 times sweeter than sugar, and the sweetest part of the leaf is a mind-boggling 300 times sweeter.

The down side was the powder didn’t melt in my tea and I was tired of leaf bits in my mouth. It was just a little too natural. I needed to make stevia extract. It took two ingredients and 36 hours, but most of that time was spent sleeping, hanging out with friends, and writing.

The big question is always “How does it taste?” I’ll be honest, there’s a faintly bitter aftertaste, similar to some sugar substitutes, but less than I noticed in the powdered form. Whether I notice it at all is completely dependent on the food or drink I add it to. I notice a little aftertaste in my tea, although it’s not objectionable, but not at all in my plain yogurt or salad dressings. I should emphasize: the aftertaste can be managed somewhat through the amount of time the leaves steep in alcohol, and by the level heat applied at the end.

I can’t say I’ve completely kicked sugar. It’s work in progress, like most things. But when I get sugar cravings in the afternoons or evenings, I reach for a cup of tea sweetened with my stevia extract and some fruit. Often, that’s all I need. I’m down to only a couple of desserts a week, a huge improvement. Well, except for the month of October, of course, when we all take the October Unprocessed Challenge with Andrew.

Here’s how to make your own at home.

Bottle of stevia extract sitting on a window sill
4.78 from 9 votes
Print

Homemade Stevia Extract

Making your own stevia extract couldn’t be easier. But first you need a stevia plant. I’ve heard you can buy the leaves in some specialty stores, but have yet to see them. I’d love to hear from you if you’ve seen them out there. As a note, some people use both the leaves and stems, but I feel the stems add to the bitter aftertaste. I strongly recommend only using the leaves.
Course Condiment
Cuisine American
Keyword homemade stevia extract, how to make stevia extract, make my own stevia
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 1 day 6 hours
Total Time 1 day 6 hours 10 minutes
Yield 1 bottle
Calories 10 kcal
Author Susan Pridmore

Ingredients

  • Enough stevia leaves to fill a jar don’t pack them too tightly, but they should be scrunched in
  • Enough vodka to cover the leaves

Instructions

  1. Wash the leaves, dry them, and stuff them into a clean jar. Fill the jar, loosely packing the leaves. The more leaves you have, the less time it will take to infuse the liquid.
  2. Pour enough vodka into the jar to completely cover the leaves. Vodka is commonly used for many extracts because of its neutral flavor. Place a lid on the jar and set it on the counter for at least 24 hours. Test the liquid for sweetness. You’ll taste alcohol too, but just focus on the sweetness level. Continue to steep the leaves until you reach the amount of sweetness you want, but don’t go past 48 hours. Longer than 48 hours results in a dominant bitter flavor. I steep my leaves for 30 - 36 hours.
  3. Place four layers of cheesecloth or a couple of coffee filters over the jar and strain the liquid into a small pot on the stove. Discard the leaves.
  4. Warm the liquid over medium-low heat, being careful not to bring it to a boil. I keep it at barely a simmer with an occasional bubble or two. You’ll notice the alcohol burning off right away. Continue heating the liquid for 30 minutes. The extract will darken to pale amber, and dark particles will be apparent.
  5. Strain the liquid again and pour into a small jar. The extract can be refrigerated for up to three months, so be sure to label the jar.

 

About the Author

Susan Pridmore lives with her husband just outside San Francisco and writes The Wimpy Vegetarian blog. Shortly after cooking her way through culinary school she moved her diet to mostly vegetarian, to the horror of her husband, Carnivorous Maximus. For the past three years, Susan has been creating vegetarian recipes on The Wimpy Vegetarian blog with “Wimpy Tips” for those wanting to add a little meat or fish. Susan‘s recipes have won contests run by Food52, Whole Foods, and Davidson’s Eggs, and her work has been published on the Weiser Kitchen blog and Ask Miss A. Follow her on Facebook and Pinterest.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
Recipe Rating




Name
Email

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

42 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
carolyn
carolyn
January 7, 2014 10:09 am

If you are not allowed to use vodka, what can you use instead of vodka to make the stevia –

Bob Koontz
Bob Koontz
December 8, 2013 1:10 pm

can the extract be frozen to keep it longer than 3 months? Or is this an unknown I will need to experiment with. Thanks

erica
erica
November 25, 2013 10:54 am

Vodka doesn’t have loads of sugar. In fact it’s my occasional go-to drink when I’m lowcarbing.

Mats
Mats
November 23, 2013 7:44 am

Really want to make this, but using vodka don’t that just add loads of sugar to the stevia and it kind of loses the point in making stevia extract? Because there is loads of sugar in vodka. Do you know of any other way of making it without using sugar based ingredients?

Betty
Betty
October 23, 2013 9:47 pm

Hi-
Made the stevia extract per the instructions. The resulting liquid tastes a lot like stevia leaves, sweet with an herbal flavor, but there is also a distinct vodka taste left. I steeped it for 35 minutes after it was heated. Should I steep it some more to distill off possible remaining vodka, or is this as good as it gets? I don’t want my tea to taste like vodka, although in orange juice it would be OK!

mjskit
October 21, 2013 7:38 pm

O.K. – You’ve convince me to find some stevia plants for next year. I eat way too much sugar and the powder and the extract sound like a great way to cut back. Thanks for sharing this!

Theresa Hogereheide
October 17, 2013 6:26 pm

I wonder if it would be less bitter if I did a vegetable glycerine extraction.

Brighid
Brighid
October 17, 2013 5:54 pm

Amazing timing! I have a couple stevia plants but other than doing more than snatching a leaf here or there, I haven’t done anything with them. By next week they’ll be dead. Tomorrow they’ll begin a new journey to being stevia extract!

Brighid
Brighid
October 26, 2013 10:21 pm
Reply to  Brighid

I made it, following the directions as close as possible. I really, really wanted to like it. But it tasted like vodka. Nasty! I wonder what went wrong…

ehnonymoose
ehnonymoose
October 17, 2013 5:33 pm

I got my stevia leaf at Mountainroseherbs.com

Melody
Melody
October 17, 2013 5:12 pm

Thank you so much for this post! I recently got some ground stevia leaves from a gentleman at our local farmer’s market. He had already dried and processed the leaves to a powder. Would your method work with my stevia powder?

As for the taste, I couldn’t believe how sweet just a few leaf crumbles were. I don’t know if there’s varieties of stevia leaf, but what this gentleman was offering tasted a bit like sweet tea with mint.