Seasonal Coffeehouse Treats, A Nutritional Comparison
Nov 15, 2010, Updated Jun 20, 2011
The Holidays must be upon us, because the Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte is back! All the hype got me wondering (as I’m prone to do), about the number of calories in a Pumpkin Spice Latte — and in all the other chains’ seasonal concoctions, too. ย So, here’s the Eating Rules guide to seasonal coffeehouse treats. I’m including Starbucks, Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf, and Peet’s Coffee. ย (Want to know about another chain? Let me know in the comments and I’ll do a followup.)
All of the drinks at these shops are made to order, so they can be customized to a certain degree. ย A few easy choices can mean the difference between a reasonable, 200 calorie treat and a 500+ calorie sugar and fat overload. Once you pass those first 250 or so calories, there’s a point of diminishing returns — those extra 250 just aren’t worth as much. ย My advice on the three least painful ways to curb those calories?
- Get a smaller size.
- Choose fat-free milk (or soy milk).
- Skip the whipped cream.
For comparison’s sake I’m going to assume you’re ignoring my first suggestion, and will show nutrition information for a 16 ounce (“medium” or “grande”) serving from each company. I gave green check marks to those drinks under 300 calories and 40 grams of sugar (had to meet both criteria), and red X marks to anything over 400 calories.
Starbucks
Starbucks definitely leads the genre with their uber-popular pumpkin spice latte, but they have a handful of other seasonal offerings, too. ย The Gingerbread Latte is the best option, while the Eggnog Latte is hands-down the worst. ย The Pumpkin Spice Latte lands in the middle.
Pumpkin Spice Latte
Fat-Free Milk, No Whipped Cream
260 calories, no fat, 210mg sodium, 48g sugars, 14g protein
Pumpkin Spice Latte
Whole Milk and Whipped Cream
410 calories, 10g sat fat, 17g total fat, 210mg sodium, 48g sugars
Toffee Mocha
Fat-Free Milk, No Whipped Cream
310 calories, 1g fat, 260mg sodium, 55g sugars
Toffee Mocha
Whole Milk, No Whipped Cream
380 calories, 6g sat fat, 11g total fat, ย 250mg sodium, 53g sugars
Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate
Fat-Free Milk, No Whipped Cream
400 calories, 6g sat fat, 11g total fat, 300mg sodium, 63g sugars
Salted Caramel Hot Chocolate
Whole Milk and Whipped Cream
480 cal, 12g sat fat, 20g total fat, 290mg sodium, 62g sugars
Gingerbread Latte
Fat-Free Milk, No Whipped Cream
200 calories, no fat, 140mg sodium, 36g sugars, 11g protein
Gingerbread Latte
Whole Milk and Whipped Cream
350 calories, 10g sat fat, 17g total fat, 140mg sodium, 36g sugars
Eggnog Latte
Fat-Free Milk, No Whipped Cream
450 calories, 11g sat fat, 18g total fat, 230mg sodium, 49g sugars
Eggnog Latte
Whole Milk and Whipped Cream
550 calories, 17.5g sat fat, 29g total fat, 230mg sodium, 47g sugars
Pumpkin Spice Frappuccinoยฎ Lightย Blended Beverage
No Whipped Cream
150 calories, 0.5g total fat, 240mg sodium, 22g sugars
This coled drink gets an honorable mention (though I’m not sure if they also use artificial sweeteners, which you may want to avoid.)
Pumpkin Spice Frappuccinoยฎ Blended Beverage
Whole Milk and Whipped Cream
430 calories, 9g sat fat, 14g total fat, 270mg sodium, 69g sugars
Think of this as a milkshake, with all the fat, sugar, and calories that go with it.
Coffee Bean & Tea Leaf
Coffee Bean kindly emailed me the nutritional information for their seasonal drinks (it’s not on their website), using non-fat milk and no whipped cream.
You can get each one with a ย “No Sugar Added Powder” (instead of the regular flavor powder). Take note, though: ย The No Sugar Added powder drinks still have a lot of added sugar!
Pumpkin Latte
350 cal, 3.5g fat, 56g sugars
Pumpkin Latte, No Sugar Added
270 cal, no fat, 40g sugars
Peppermint Vanilla Latte
370 cal, 4g fat, 60g sugars
Peppermint Vanilla Latte, No Sugar Added
300 calories, 0.5g fat, 44g sugars
Peppermint Mocha Latte
370 cal, 3g fat, 59g sugars
Peppermint Mocha Latte, No Sugar Added
300 cal, 0.5g fat, 44g sugars
Gingerbread Cookie Latte
370 calories, 3.5g fat, 59g sugars
Gingerbread Cookie Latte, No Sugar Added
290 calories, no fat, 43g sugars
Red Velvet Hot Chocolate
460 calories, 13g fat, 55g sugars
Tea Latte with Vanilla Powder
280 calories, 7g fat, 44g sugars
Tea Latte with Vanilla Powder, No Sugar Added
120 calories, no fat, 11g sugars
Holiday Flavor Ice Blended Drinks
Gingerbread Cookie, Red Velvet, Pumpkin, Peppermint Vanilla, and Peppermint Mocha
460-480 calories, 8-17g fat, 55-81g sugars
Holiday Flavor Ice Blended Drinks, No Sugar Added
Gingerbread Cookie, Pumpkin, Peppermint Vanilla, and Peppermint Mocha
220-240 calories, 0-0.5g fat, 31-35g sugars
Pumpkin Spice Coffee &ย Holiday Blend Coffee
These are nutritionally about the same as any other brewed coffee — so it’s about 5 calories per serving (before adding milk or sugar, of course). ย A great way to get the holiday flavor without the holiday calories!
Peet’s Coffee
Peet’s kindly emailed me the nutritional information for their seasonal drinks (itโs not on their website), using non-fat milk and no whipped cream.
Pumpkin Spice Caffe Latte
Fat-Free Milk
222 calories, no fat, 202mg sodium, 40g sugars
Pumpkin Spice Caffe Latte
Whole Milk
327 calories, 8g sat fat, 12g total fat, 188mg sodium, 43g sugars
Peppermint Caffe Mocha
Fat-Free Milk
286 calories, 1g fat, 203mg sodium, 52g sugars
Peppermint Caffe Mocha
Whole Milk
384 calories, 7g sat fat, 12g total fat, 196mg sodium, 51g sugars
Gingerbread Caffe Latte
Fat-Free Milk
234 calories, no fat, 195mg sodium, 44g sugars
Gingerbread Caffe Latte
Whole Milk
339 calories, 8g sat fat, 12g total fat, 188mg sodium, 43g sugars
Eggnog Latte
650 calories, 20g sat fat, 29g total fat, 553mg sodium, 75g sugars
—
Menu Mondays areย myย recommendations for the most healthful options at chain restaurants. Although it may be tough to find โperfectโ options when eating out, itโs important to choose โbetterโ whenever possible, and I hope these guides will help make that easier for you.
indicates the โbest-of-the-best,โ and indicates the โworst-of-the-worst,” more or less. ย In this round, I gave green check marks to those drinks under 300 calories and 40 grams of sugar (had to meet both criteria), and red X marks to anything over 400 calories.
Photo by Zach Hale.
Wow, this article helps for good travel & taste the yummy food…I appreciate it thanks.
Excellent post!
Sorry, new to this whole thing, but isn’t cream from milk a healthy kind of fat.. in one of your other posts about milk you recommended whole milk over skim. So wouldn’t unsweetened whipping cream (not talking about the stuff out of a can) actually be a good option in your coffee? Actually less processed than skim milk or even soy milk for that matter.
Hi Elijah,
Did you see this recent post of mine? It might help answer your question:
http://www.eatingrules.com/2012/01/what-kind-of-milk-should-i-drink/
Best,
Andrew